Unique & Historic Hotels

Lodging comes in many forms in Suffolk County, so why stick to the ordinary? You can book rooms in grand Suffolk County, New York historic hotels, cozy cottages, a sprawling historic mansion or a secluded island retreat, just to name a few. Each of these unique and historic hotels in New York offers supreme service and comfort – just what you need on a leisurely getaway.

Browse some of the most interesting and historic hotels in New York’s Suffolk County below and start planning for a Long Island vacation you won’t soon forget.

Use our INTERACTIVE MAP to search for Suffolk County, New York historic hotels by area.

The list of hotels in this section is based on the hotel tax collection records of Suffolk County. A listing here does not constitute an endorsement by the Long Island Convention & Visitors Bureau.

Farm Stands
Select All
4 Results

1708 House, The

126 Main Street / Southampton, NY 11968 / 631 287 1708

A beautiful, luxurious historical B&B located in the heart of Southampton Village, 1 mile from the ocean. Various room types - traditional, deluxe, suites...

Baker House, The

181 Main Street / East Hampton, NY 11937 / 631 324 4081

Nestled in the beautiful, historic Village of East Hampton, NY, The Baker House 1650 is a masterpiece of 17th Century Cotswold-inspired architecture. While...

c/o The Maidstone Hotel

207 Main Street / East Hampton, NY 11937 / 631 324 5006

Inn Open Year Round Restaurant, room service, cocktail lounge, non-smoking rooms, walk to...

Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

290 Old Montauk Highway / Montauk, NY 11954 / 631 668 2345

Situated on Montauk’s most pristine stretch of oceanfront real estate, Gurney’s Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a Hampton’s icon and the only...